Friday Night Lights: Keep them turned on
This is Part 3 in the reviews of new television shows I'm watchingBefore I get started, can I just say, you're probably all thinking "No wonder she didn't become a writer!" Seriously, I know these headlines are ridiculous...I'm mostly doing them to be silly. Mostly.
That said, I should also note that it is impossible for me to review this without talking about the book on which it is based, and it is impossible for me to discuss the show without some major spoilers of both. You have been warned!
Even though I hate most sports, and football in particular, I have enjoyed many a book, television program, and/or movie about high school football. One, the high school element always makes me happy. Two, assuming it's remotely serious and thoughtful about it (rather than a rah-rah "Will Johnny score the winning touchdown and earn the head cheerleader's love?"-type deal), I love the glimpses into someone else's life, a life completely foreign from my own, where football is actually remotely important. On one of my ill-fated interviews recently, the interviewer observed, "When you majored in Creative Writing, you specialized in narrative fiction, didn't you?" Why, yes, I did, and why did he ask? Well, because apparently I'd said more than once that I liked hearing people's "stories." That's the type of non-fiction I like the best--a year in the life type slice of what's going on with a group of people, particularly if they're very different from my own life, to get insight into something I haven't experienced.
Friday Night Lights the book is most certainly a life not led by me or anybody I know. It's the story of a small, poor town in Texas where the most important thing going on is the high school's football team and where, if you're one of its players, the high point of your life will be your role on the team. After you graduate? It's all downhill from there. The book was later turned into a movie, and now here it is on television every week. How will it go?
I mostly really, really liked it a lot. There were some definitely cheesy moments (like when the half-drunk football player toasted "To football! To Texas!"), but one of the high points is that it didn't feel like a pilot. You know, with Basil Exposition all explaining so much shit that the
real action doesn't occur until week two. Yes, we had to learn who all these players were, but it was mostly done very seamlessly, e.g., when the star quarterback was interviewed by the NBC affiliate. In addition, the cinematography (if that's still the word you use when referring to television vs. movies) was really gritty, which sounds like a weird compliment but made it look very different from a glossy happy television show. They even actually made a football game--usually the moment at which I fast-forward, or, if reading a book, flip ahead--interesting and suspenseful. So go Peter Berg (writer/director of the pilot, and director of the movie) (also director of one of my all-time favorite failed shows, Wonderland, starring the awesome Martin Donovan and Michelle Forbes. Le sigh) for those accomplishments!
My biggest complaint is where it diverged from the book. I can't help it, I am a purist when it comes to adapting books into movies/television. If you make a change, and I can't figure out why you did it, I'm going to be annoyed. Sometimes it does make sense--e.g.,
About a Boy, which has a very long scene in the book where Marcus and Ellie wander off mourning the death of Kurt Cobain. Well, the movie came out 10 years later and was set in the present...that wouldn't really make sense. So that's okay. In this case (spoilers, spoilers, spoilers!) the change is surrounding the Big Injury. In
Friday Night Lights the television show, in Game 1 of the new head coach's season, the star quarterback who we've already heard such hyperbole about as "The best I've seen in 25 years of recruiting for Notre Dame," who calls the mayor "ma'am," who interviews charmingly, who has two loving caring parents, who even loves his virgin girlfriend over the town slut, is critically injured. Like, will he ever walk again? injured. This happens in the middle of a really close second half where it's not obvious at all who will win the game, and he's carried off in a stretcher and the whole town proceeds to Freak Out.
In the book, however, there are two
major differences. One, the outcome of the game was a foregone conclusion (they were going to win), and the coach had the guy playing anyway rather than letting some second- and third-stringers off the bench. Two, and much more disturbingly in terms of "why make the change," the kid was black, poor, had family problems (I've forgotten the specifics but he was living with his uncle throughout the book), and was, at best, brash and kind of obnoxious. Football was this kid's chance to go to college and get out of the depressed town, given the fact he could barely read and was passed through the years on the basis of his athleticism. The injury wasn't as immediately serious in the book--it was never a question of whether he would walk again. Unfortunately, it did wind up basically ruining him because he never played as well again, and a huge chunk of the book is watching him sort of completely fall apart and not really recover, ever. In addition, the coach got a
lot of heat for playing him when "he really shouldn't have."
What the book did so well was examine a lot of the underlying racism that still existed in this town and how it applied to the football players. Actually, it wasn't even underlying--people flat out called some of the team the n-word in casual conversation, not even pejoratively, as if they were saying nothing more innocuous than "boys" or "players." And to see how the attitude towards this star shifted when he was no longer the star, and how his race and class played so much into the shifting attitude towards him, was incredibly fascinating.
So I have to ask, why this change for the television show? Making the player likeable and white, and from a stable loving family with all the breaks in the world he could ever ask for tells a completely different story, and one that makes a lot fewer people really uncomfortable. A lot more people are going to immediately viscerally respond to a Golden Boy's fall than someone like the actual person (unfortunately nicknamed Boobie) to whom this happened. In addition, a great deal of the book centered around the town's, and the coach's, second-guessing the decision to play Boobie when they didn't "need" him to play. It's clear in the show they need him to play if they want to win. What both of these changes do is make the show a lot more clear-cut, a lot less ambiguous, and a lot less messy. We're not questioning if building Boobie up to be a big football star at the expense of anything else in his life (namely his ability to READ, for god's sake) was the smartest thing for him...we're not questioning if the whole "you WILL be a football star" thing happened in part because of his race and class, and how this was maybe seen as the way you get a poor black kid out of his situation. Instead, we're feeling for Golden Boy and how his whole world is falling apart! But we fundamentally know he'll bounce back, because he's Golden Boy. In real life, something like that doesn't always happen. It didn't happen to Boobie. And the show, while still very good and one that I want to watch again, does a disservice to the message of the book by making that change.